LORETO, PERU – A developing crisis in the heart of the Peruvian Amazon is putting long-standing local conservation efforts against one of the world’s largest environmental organizations. Dr. Paul Beaver, a biologist with over 46 years of experience in the region, is sounding the alarm on what he describes as the “severe impact” of programs introduced by the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) within the Area de Conservación Regional Comunal Tamshiyacu Tahuayo (ACRCTT).
For decades, the ACRCTT was celebrated as a gold standard for community-led conservation, seeing a dramatic recovery of endangered species like the Pink Dolphin, Amazon River Manatee, and the Giant River Otter. However, since the COVID-19 pandemic, Paul claims that new commercial initiatives have begun to reverse the progress him, his team, and the local communities have fought for.
According to Paul, the WCS entered the ACRCTT, an area already having a successful conservation record, and implemented large-scale commercial fishing and hunting operations. While these programs are marketed as “regulated,” Paul observes that there has been extraction to a degree never seen before in the reserve.
There really wasn’t any commercial hunting or fishing or any degree of over hunting or fishing before they got involved, and now there is. It’s had really bad impacts. Some of our partner NGOs have even pulled out of the area. One significant one in particular used to be known as the Manatee Center of Iquitos, Centro de Rescate de Amazonía (CREA), which partners with the Dallas World Aquarium… [they] had a manatee conservation project they were doing with us for over 10 years in the Tahuayo River. After two of their manatees… had died in fishing nets provided by the WCS and several more had gone missing, they decided to pull out.
The biological data reflecting this shift is stark. The most visible indicator of the ecosystem’s health, the population of fishing birds, has plummeted. Research conducted in early 2025 was compared to previously published data, revealing significant negative impact.
…between the two species of birds, it was between a 46 to 60% decline in the number of yellow-headed caracara and black-collared hawks, birds that depend on fishing.
Paul believes that WCS leadership is disconnected from the reality on the ground, noting that they rarely have a physical presence in the deep reserve to monitor the impacts of their policies.
I would dispute that there’s any more than 20 work hours every two years from somebody from their society down here to look at things… their leadership clearly has never been here.
While government agencies have indicated that commercial hunting in areas with endangered species may be illegal, Paul is hesitant to call for a forced shutdown, fearing it would damage the community relations necessary to run his foundation’s schools and hospital. Instead, his team is pivoting toward alternative livelihoods, such as chicken and egg production, to draw community members away from the destructive commercial trade.
The initiative seeks to draw the community away from the river’s fragile ecosystems by providing a more reliable source of income and added food security. Unlike commercial fishing, which is restricted to the dry season, poultry production offers a year-round economic base.
We think we can develop a year-round economic base… commercial fishing is only an economic base in the dry season… [this] would better serve the community with extra cash and yet have no impact on the forest.
Paul notes that while community members are already on board and eager to participate, the WCS has declined to partner on this transition.
Despite this, the project remains the primary hope for a “voluntary” shift that could allow the Pink Dolphins, Manatees, and Giant River Otters to continue to thrive in the Tahuayo.
Ayni Studios has attempted to contact the Wildlife Conservation Society on multiple occasions for a response to this issue. There has been no response from their side at this time.
CASE_001 [A SURVIVING ECOSYSTEM] OVERVIEW:
For years, local communities, NGOs, and private businesses worked in harmony to establish and maintain the ACR CTT (Área de Conservación Regional Comunal Tamshiyacu Tahuayo). Since its inception, local wildlife and economic opportunities have flourished; however, the situation shifted drastically following the introduction of a commercial fishing programme initiated by the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS).
Since the programme’s launch, communities have faced mounting challenges fuelled by overfishing, which has led to a decline in keystone species and a subsequent threat to critically endangered animals. Furthermore, the overall reduction in biodiversity has severely hindered ecotourism operations, the region’s economic backbone.
A decline in tourism triggers a devastating domino effect:
Social Safety Nets: Local NGOs face a resource shortage, limiting their ability to fund early childhood programmes that combat criminal activities like human trafficking.
Economic Equity: Small, women-led community businesses face insolvency due to the lack of visitors.
Public Health & Education: Funding for local hospitals and health initiatives is dwindling, while research and higher education opportunities at local centers risk total cessation.
Communities, local government, NGOs, and private businesses must act quickly and decisively to prevent a once-thriving ecosystem from collapsing into one that can barely survive.
To stay update to date on this case, or to learn more on how to help, please contact us using this form below:
